Skip to content
ALEXANDER · JOURNAL · Diamanti

How to choose an engagement ring: the complete 2026 guide

In short: Start from three questions: the style of the person who will wear it, the budget you can afford, and whether you prefer a diamond or a coloured stone. The main families are solitaire, trilogy, eternity and veretta. In Italy it is worn on the ring finger of the left hand and in most cases it can be resized by 1–2 sizes.

Choosing the engagement ring is one of the most important decisions before a marriage proposal. It is not just a piece of jewellery: it is a symbol that holds a promise, a personal taste and — let's be honest — a significant investment. In this guide we take you step by step through the choice, with the practical advice we would give a customer in our shop.

How to choose an engagement ring

Before walking into a jeweller's — or browsing a catalogue online — it is worth pausing on three key questions:

  1. What is the style of the person who will wear it? Look at the jewellery they usually wear. Do they prefer fine lines or statement pieces? Classic yellow gold or cool tones such as white gold? An engagement ring is perfect when it reflects the person receiving it, not the trends of the moment.
  2. How much do you realistically want to spend? Forget the old “three months' salary” rule: set a budget that lets you live comfortably the month after the proposal too. We look at price ranges in detail further on.
  3. Diamond or coloured stone? The diamond remains the most popular choice for tradition and durability (10 on the Mohs scale), but sapphires, rubies and emeralds are gaining ground with those looking for something unique.

A tip we often give in the shop: don't underestimate the setting. Two rings with the same diamond can look completely different depending on the setting, the profile of the band and the finish. The setting is what makes the piece personal.

Engagement ring styles

The market offers dozens of variations, but the vast majority of engagement rings fall into four families. Knowing them helps you narrow the field before even talking about stones or metals.

Solitaire ring

The solitaire ring is the undisputed king of proposals: a single central stone — almost always a diamond — mounted on a plain or lightly worked band. Its strength lies in its simplicity: all the visual impact is concentrated on the gem. It suits those who love understated elegance and want a piece that will never go out of fashion.

The most popular cut for a solitaire is the round brilliant, which maximises light refraction. However, the oval and cushion cuts have grown a lot in recent years, because they give the illusion of a larger stone for the same carat weight.

Trilogy ring

The trilogy — also called “past, present, future” — holds three stones in a row, with the central one larger than the side stones. Symbolically it represents the couple's past, present and future. It is the ideal choice for those who want more sparkle than a solitaire without going as far as a band fully set with stones.

A well-designed trilogy engagement ring balances the three stones harmoniously: the central one usually weighs about twice each side stone (for example 0.50 ct + 0.25 ct + 0.25 ct).

Eternity ring

The eternity ring features a continuous row of diamonds that encircles the whole band — or at least the visible half (half eternity). It symbolises never-ending love. It is very striking, but bear in mind that a full eternity ring cannot easily be resized, so the size must be perfect from the start.

Veretta

The veretta is similar to the eternity but with smaller, closely set stones, often channel set. The result is an elegant, low-profile band that is comfortable to wear every day. Many choose it as a wedding band to pair with the solitaire, but it also works beautifully as an engagement ring for those who prefer a minimalist style.

Discover the Salvini collection
Solitaires, trilogies and wedding bands crafted with Italian artisan mastery.
View the collection →

The 4Cs of diamonds: a summary

If you choose a diamond, you need to know the 4Cs: Carat, Cut, Colour and Clarity. These are the parameters used internationally to assess a diamond's quality and, consequently, its price.

  • Carat: indicates the weight of the stone. One carat equals 0.20 grams. Note: carat alone does not determine perceived size — much depends on the cut and shape.
  • Cut: the parameter that most affects brilliance. An “Excellent” or “Very Good” cut makes the stone look brighter and livelier, even at a lower carat weight.
  • Colour: the scale runs from D (perfectly colourless) to Z (visible yellow). For an engagement ring, grades G to I offer excellent value for money: they look white to the naked eye.
  • Clarity: measures internal inclusions. VS2 (Very Slightly Included 2) is the sweet spot: inclusions are invisible without a 10x loupe and the price is much lower than higher grades.

We have prepared an in-depth guide to the 4Cs of diamonds with comparisons and tips for every budget. We recommend reading it before you decide.

Metals: white, yellow or rose gold?

The choice of metal is not just aesthetic — it affects the ring's durability, the maintenance it needs and how it pairs with other jewellery.

White gold (18 kt)

White gold is the most requested metal for diamond engagement rings. Its neutral tone enhances the transparency of the stone and goes easily with any wardrobe. One thing to note: the rhodium plating (the rhodium bath that gives it its bright silvery colour) tends to wear over time. A refresh at the jeweller's every 12–18 months keeps the ring looking new.

Yellow gold (18 kt)

Yellow gold is the great classic of Italian jewellery. Warmer and more traditional, it needs no rhodium plating and develops a much-appreciated natural patina. Bear in mind that yellow gold can make stones of colour J and below look slightly warmer.

Rose gold (18 kt)

Rose gold has been the strongest trend of recent years. Its romantic, vintage tone makes it particularly suited to those looking for an engagement ring with a personal, contemporary style.

Platinum

Platinum is the most precious metal: naturally white, hypoallergenic and incredibly durable. It costs more than 18 kt gold (on average 30–50% more) but needs no rhodium plating and literally lasts a lifetime without changing.

For a detailed comparison of gold alloys, read our guide to the differences between yellow, white and rose gold.

Engagement ring: budget and price ranges

Let's talk real numbers. The price of an engagement ring varies enormously depending on stone, setting and brand. Here is a realistic overview for the Italian market in 2026:

  • €500 – €1,500: rings with a 0.10–0.30 ct diamond in an 18 kt gold setting. Perfect for young couples or those who prefer to invest more in the experience (trip, ceremony). Don't underestimate this range: a well-made ring with a small but excellently cut diamond is more beautiful than a large, dull one.
  • €1,500 – €3,500: the most popular range. It allows a 0.30–0.50 ct diamond with good characteristics (G–H colour, VS clarity) in branded settings such as Salvini or Davite & Delucchi.
  • €3,500 – €7,000: solitaires with a higher-quality 0.50–0.80 ct diamond, or important trilogies. This is where GIA- or IGI-certified stones come in, a recommended choice above 0.50 ct.
  • Over €7,000: diamonds of 1 ct and above, fancy stones (yellow, pink), platinum settings or one-off pieces. The investment is considerable, but a certified diamond of this size holds its value over time.

Practical tip: if your budget is limited, invest in the cut rather than the carats. A 0.40 ct diamond with an Excellent cut sparkles more — and looks bigger — than a 0.50 ct with a Good cut.

Explore engagement rings
Solitaires, trilogies and much more: find your ideal ring in our catalogue.
Discover the rings →

How to find the right ring size

Guessing the size without spoiling the surprise is probably the most stressful part of the whole operation. Here are the methods that really work:

  1. Borrow a ring they already wear. If they wear a ring on the ring finger of the right hand, that size is almost always right for the left too (or at most half a size smaller). Bring it to the shop: we will measure it free of charge in a few seconds.
  2. Ask a trusted friend for help. Close friends often know this information — or can find it out discreetly.
  3. Use the string trick. While they sleep, gently wrap a piece of string around the left ring finger, mark the closing point and measure the length in millimetres. It is the least accurate method, but better than nothing.
  4. Buy with a resizing guarantee. At Alexander Gioielli every ring includes the first resizing free of charge. If the size is not perfect, we correct it at no extra cost.

Indicative table of the most common Italian sizes:

IT size Diameter (mm) Circumference (mm)
1016.050.3
1216.551.8
1417.254.0
1617.855.9
1818.558.1

Mistakes to avoid when choosing an engagement ring

In many years of experience we have seen the same mistakes repeated. Here are five you can easily avoid:

  1. Buying on carats alone. A large diamond with a mediocre cut (Good or Fair) will look dull and milky. Cut comes before weight: always.
  2. Ignoring the wearer's lifestyle. If they work with their hands, a solitaire in a high prong setting will constantly catch. A lower setting (bezel setting) or a veretta is better.
  3. Not asking for the stone's certificate. For diamonds over 0.30 ct, always insist on a GIA, IGI or HRD certificate. The certificate is the stone's identity card and your objective guarantee.
  4. Being guided only by the lowest price online. A price that is too low often hides stones with strong fluorescence (which makes them look cloudy in daylight) or colour/clarity grades inflated by less rigorous laboratories.
  5. Forgetting how it pairs with the wedding band. The engagement ring will be worn together with the wedding band for decades. Think from the start about how the two rings will sit on the same finger: profile, height and metal should harmonise.

Frequently asked questions about engagement rings

How much is spent on average on an engagement ring in Italy?

According to industry data, average spending in Italy is between €1,500 and €3,000. But there is no “right” figure: the budget must be sustainable for the couple. At Alexander Gioielli we offer options in every range, from diamond solitaires starting at around €1,350 to the most important trilogies and verettas.

Natural diamond or lab-grown diamond?

Lab-grown diamonds have the same physical and chemical properties as natural diamonds, but cost 60–80% less. They are a legitimate and increasingly popular choice, especially for those who want a larger stone on the same budget. Natural diamonds, on the other hand, hold their value better over time and carry the charm of rarity. The choice is personal: both options are valid.

Which finger is the engagement ring worn on?

In Italy the engagement ring is traditionally worn on the ring finger of the left hand. After the wedding, many women move it to the right hand or stack it with the wedding band on the same hand.

Can an engagement ring be resized?

In most cases yes, within 1–2 sizes up or down. Exceptions are full eternity rings (with stones all around the band) and some models with special engravings. That is why it is always best to get as close as possible to the correct size at the time of purchase.

When is the right time to buy the ring?

We recommend starting your search at least 4–6 weeks before the planned proposal date. If you want a made-to-measure ring or a stone with specific characteristics, allow 8–10 weeks. Ordering at the last minute limits your options and increases stress — exactly the opposite of what you need.

Need help choosing?

Visit us in our shop in Battipaglia or contact us: we will guide you in choosing the perfect ring, with no obligation.

Contact us →

Article updated September 2026. Information on prices and availability refers to the Alexander Gioielli catalogue in Battipaglia (SA) and may vary.